Piccadilly Dental AlliancePiccadilly Dental Alliance
← Insights#05 · RESEARCH

Who stays, and why.

Early findings from the PDA Index on clinician retention, and what they say about how a practice should be built.

Piccadilly Dental Alliance5 min read2026
01

The wrong question

Retention in dentistry is usually discussed as a pay problem. Raise the offer, add a signing bonus, and the dentist will stay.

Compensation matters, and no one stays long in a role that does not reward them fairly. But when we looked at our own clinicians, pay explained less about who stayed than we expected. Dentists who left rarely did so for a marginally better number. They left because something about the practice had stopped working for them.

So we started asking a different question. Not “what does it cost to keep a dentist?” but “what does a dentist need from a practice to want to build a career there?”

02

What we can see

Most retention data in dental groups starts at acquisition. By then, a practice already has a history: its culture, its team and its habits were formed by someone else. Clinicians who leave in the first year may be leaving a practice the group never really shaped.

Because we build every office ourselves, the PDA Index can follow a clinician from their first day in an office we opened. We see how onboarding went, who they worked alongside, how their schedule developed, and how their clinical responsibilities grew over time, all inside one shared operating standard.

When every office runs on the same system, the differences between those who stay and those who leave start to mean something.
03

Four early findings

These are early patterns, not final conclusions. The full analysis will be published in the PDA Index. But four themes have appeared consistently enough to share now.

i.The first year decides more than the contract.How a dentist is welcomed, supported and mentored in the first twelve months shapes their tenure more than the terms they signed.
ii.Dentists stay with teams, not titles.Clinicians with a stable assistant and front-desk team tend to stay. When a team turns over, the dentist often follows.
iii.Autonomy outweighs perks.Dentists who make their own treatment decisions, within a shared clinical standard, report stronger commitment than those offered flexibility alone.
iv.A visible path keeps people.Clinicians who can see where they could be in five years, whether as a mentor, lead dentist or partner, are far more likely to still be with us.

None of these is surprising to anyone who has practiced. What is new is being able to see them across a network, in offices built the same way from the start.

04

What we are changing

Findings only matter if they change how we operate. Three things are already different.

Onboarding is treated as clinical work. Every new dentist is paired with an experienced clinician for their first months, with regular case reviews rather than a single orientation day.

Team stability is a leadership measure. Office leaders are accountable for keeping clinical teams together, because we now know a dentist’s tenure depends on it.

Growth is mapped, not promised. Each clinician has a written development path, from advanced training to mentoring to leading an office, reviewed with them every year.

05

What comes next

Retention is not a perk program or a compensation strategy. It is the result of how a practice is built and run, day after day.

The PDA Index will publish the full findings, including how retention relates to clinical quality, office growth and patient loyalty. We will update it every year, so what begins as early patterns can become a long-term view of what keeps great dentists in practice.

Explore the PDA Index →
THE TAKEAWAY

Dentists rarely leave a paycheck. They leave a practice that stopped helping them grow.

Build the practice well, and retention follows.

KEEP READINGAll insights →
#06 · MARKET VIEWWhat the next generation of dentists wants.7 min read→RESEARCH · THE PDA INDEXWhat keeps great dentists.Inaugural edition→